How many half-finished Google Docs or Trello boards do you have titled “Startup Ideas”? If you’re anything like me, the answer is… too many. The excitement of a new project is intoxicating, but finding the one—the idea that has actual legs—can feel like searching for a specific needle in a giant, continent-sized haystack of needles. It's a unique form of paralysis. You're motivated, you have the skills, but you're just stuck on the starting line.
For years, my process was a chaotic mess of late-night Reddit scrolling, blindly chasing whatever was hot on Hacker News, and trying to mash two existing ideas together, hoping for a spark. It sometimes worked. More often, it led to a cool-but-useless side project that taught me a new framework but didn’t solve a real problem. So when a tool called Pick My Niche floated across my screen, claiming to use AI to find profitable app ideas, my inner skeptic and my hopeful entrepreneur sides both sat up and paid attention.
Is this just another AI-hype-train gimmick, or is it the cheat code for idea generation we’ve all been waiting for? I had to find out.
What Exactly is Pick My Niche?
At its core, Pick My Niche is an AI-powered idea discovery platform. But that's a bit of a dry, corporate way to put it. A better description? It’s like having a tiny, caffeinated research assistant who spends all day, every day, eavesdropping on Reddit conversations to find out what people are complaining about. It listens for problems, frustrations, and wishes, then uses AI to package those pain points into tangible web and mobile app ideas. Simple as that.
It was created by Mfi Marek, a Framer developer who, according to his own story on the site, got tired of the exact struggle I just described. This isn't some faceless corporation churning out another AI wrapper. It feels like a tool built by a fellow tinkerer, which immediately made me more interested. It's a solution born from a real, relatable frustration.
Visit Pick My Niche
Going Beyond a Simple Idea List: The Core Features
Okay, so it spits out ideas. Lots of tools do that. Where Pick My Niche really started to win me over was in the how. It’s not just a random word generator.
AI-Driven Insights, Not Just Keywords
This is the secret sauce. The AI isn't just looking for “most mentioned” keywords. It’s attempting to understand context and sentiment. Instead of just flagging “CRM” as a popular topic, it might unearth a thread in a niche subreddit where users are saying, “I wish there was a super-simple CRM for my dog-walking business that didn’t have all this enterprise junk.” That’s a real, actionable insight. It’s the difference between knowing the ocean is big and knowing exactly where the fish are biting.
The Reddit Goldmine
Why Reddit? Because it's a beautifully chaotic treasure trove of unfiltered human opinion. People go there to complain, to ask for solutions, and to share their weirdly specific problems. It's a focus group that you don’t have to pay for. Pick My Niche curates discussions from subreddits like r/SaaS, r/Entrepreneur, and other business-focused communities, which is smart. It’s mining for gold in a proven goldfield, saving you the hours of manual scrolling.
From Idea to Action Plan with Full Documentation
This, for me, is the game-changer. An idea is great, but a one-sentence idea is a long way from an actual product. Pick My Niche provides what it calls “Full Idea Documentation.” This includes things like potential technical specifications, user flows, and monetization strategies. It gives you a running start. It takes the idea from a vague concept and turns it into the first page of a project plan. That alone can save days, if not weeks, of head-scratching and wireframing.
Sanity-Checking with Google Trends
I love this feature. It's a built-in reality check. A group of 10 people on Reddit might be VERY passionate about a problem, but if nobody else on the planet is searching for a solution, your potential market is… well, those 10 people. Integrating Google Trends directly into the platform lets you instantly validate if a niche has any real-world traction. It’s a simple, brilliant way to avoid building something for a market that doesn’t exist.
Let's Talk Money: The Pick My Niche Pricing
Alright, this is the part that made me do a double-take. In a world of never-ending monthly subscriptions, Pick My Niche is running an early adopter offer that’s pretty wild. I've seen a lot of SaaS pricing models, and this one stands out.
| Plan | Price | Details |
|---|---|---|
| Early Adopter Lifetime Access | $149 | One-time payment. You get everything, forever. All features, all future updates. |
| Regular Price (Future) | $29/month | That's $348 per year. The math on the lifetime deal speaks for itself. |
I have a love-hate relationship with Lifetime Deals (LTDs). They can be risky. You're betting on the company sticking around and continuing to develop the product. But when they pay off, they really pay off. In this case, for less than the cost of five months of the future subscription, you get lifetime access. If you're serious about finding a SaaS or app idea in the next year, the value proposition is, frankly, a bit of a no-brainer. It's a low-cost bet on a potentially high-value tool.
The Not-So-Shiny Bits (Because Nothing's Perfect)
No review is honest without looking at the potential downsides. While I’m genuinely excited about this tool, there are a few things to keep in mind.
- The Reddit Box. Right now, the tool's strength—its focus on Reddit—is also a limitation. There are valuable conversations happening on Twitter, Indie Hackers, LinkedIn, and countless other forums. The good news is that “Expanded Data Sources” is on their public roadmap, so they know this is an area for growth.
- The AI Crystal Ball. Let's be real, AI is not magic. The quality of the ideas is entirely dependent on the AI's analysis. You're still going to get some duds. You still need to apply your own experience and intuition. Think of Pick My Niche as a powerful assistant, not an infallible oracle. Its job is to bring you interesting rocks; your job is to know which ones are gems.
- A Note on Future Costs. The website mentions that some “future advanced features using generative AI may require in-app purchases.” This is a little vague, but it’s something to be aware of. The LTD covers the core product, but super-advanced, resource-intensive features down the line might cost extra. That's fairly standard, but its good to know upfront.
Who Is This Tool Actually For?
I see a few groups getting a ton of value out of this:
The Indie Hacker & Solopreneur: This is the bullseye. If you’re a developer or builder tired of searching for your next micro-SaaS, this is designed for you. It automates the painful research phase.
The Agency Owner or Freelancer: Stuck for a new service offering? Use this to spot niche problems you could solve for clients. You might even find an idea for a small tool that could become a productized service for your agency.
The SEO & Content Marketer: Me! Even if you’re not building an app, understanding user pain points is the foundation of good SEO and content strategy. This is a great tool for finding blog topics, lead magnets, or free tools that will attract your target audience.
It's probably not for the enterprise team looking for their next billion-dollar venture or someone who wants a fully guaranteed, market-tested business plan handed to them on a silver platter. It's a starting point, a powerful catalyst for the creative and entrepreneurial process.
My Final Take: Is Pick My Niche a Buy?
Yeah, I think so. Especially with the current lifetime deal.
Pick My Niche doesn’t promise you a unicorn. It doesn't guarantee your next idea will be a runaway success. What it does is solve a very real, very frustrating problem: the empty page. It gives you smart, data-informed, and well-contextualized starting points. It cuts through the noise and turns raw community chatter into structured opportunities.
For a one-time cost of $149, you're buying a perpetual idea machine that could genuinely spark your next successful project. It's an investment in overcoming inertia. If you’re a builder, a creator, or an entrepreneur who has felt that painful friction of being stuck in “idea mode,” this might just be the push you need to finally get moving.
Frequently Asked Questions about Pick My Niche
What is Pick My Niche for?
Pick My Niche is an AI-powered platform designed to help entrepreneurs, developers, and marketers discover profitable business ideas for web and mobile apps. It analyzes trending discussions on Reddit to find user problems and turns them into actionable ideas.
How does the AI actually find these business ideas?
The AI sifts through conversations in curated, business-oriented subreddits. It's programmed to identify pain points, feature requests, and gaps in the market mentioned by users, then structures this data into a complete idea with technical suggestions and validation.
Is the $149 a one-time payment or a subscription?
The $149 price is a special one-time payment for the Early Adopter Lifetime Deal. This gives you permanent access to the tool and its future updates. The regular pricing is planned to be a $29/month subscription, so the LTD offers significant savings.
What makes Pick My Niche different from other idea generators?
Most idea generators provide random or vague one-line prompts. Pick My Niche provides data-backed ideas based on real user conversations and includes full idea documentation—like technical specs and user flows—plus integrated Google Trends data for quick validation.
Can I trust ideas that only come from Reddit?
Reddit is a powerful source for raw, honest feedback, making it a great starting point. However, you should always treat these ideas as a foundation. It's crucial to do your own further research and validation. The platform's roadmap also includes plans to add more data sources in the future.
Who is behind Pick My Niche?
The platform was created by Mfi Marek, a Framer developer and indie hacker who built the tool to solve his own problem of finding viable side-project ideas.
Reference and Sources
- Pick My Niche Official Website (Note: This is a placeholder link for the purpose of this article)
